We’ve reported previously that Walton-financed researchers at the Walton-financed University of Arkansas believe they have proven by scientific research that Walmart-fortune-financed (Walker Foundation) field trips to the Walton-financed Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art in Bentonville are valuable to students.
Message: School districts, load your buses and head to Walton(Benton)ville!
We reported earlier also that the University of Arkansas resisted Freedom of Information Act requests about the survey work, preferring to delay full release until a media event today. It’s another example of the UA’s ongoing Walton exception to rigorous compliance with the state’s sunshine law. It goes along with the Razorback exception and the Brother Honky Arkansas Foundation exception.
I’ll break from my sarcasm for a moment to repeat what I said when this news first broke. I believe in the broadening value of a liberal arts education and believe that fine arts can lift students (and adults, too). Crystal Bridges is a fine museum, a prism-like treasure that offers new discoveries on each re-examination.
But there’s a touch of irony in this Walton museum rear-smooching from Jay Greene, one of the Walton-financed researchers at the Waltons’ so-called education reform unit at Walton U.:
Culturally enriching field trips are in decline in public education, and museums across the country report a steep drop in school tours,” Greene said.
Nobody dare suggest that a drop in field trips could be related to the all-consuming focus on standardized tests being promoted by the Waltons and others in the Billionaire Boys Club. Might the drop [if indeed there’s empirical research to demonstrate this is so] relate to the billionaires’ persistent complaint that school performance is unrelated to money and, thus, spending is being strangled to the extent possible by legislators typically supported by Walton money? Might it be that field trips go first when tax support is lagging? Could it be that teachers who don’t demonstrate sufficient improvement in the scores of even the most deprived of students are constantly told they need to spend more time on task and test prep and less on off-curriculum activities, lest they be viewed as lazy entertainers rather than educators?
Some more research is needed, clearly.
The full news release is on the jump.
Study finds positive effects for students visiting Crystal Bridges
Follow the University of Arkansas on Twitter @uarkansas
BENTONVILLE, Ark. – Researchers in the College of Education and Health Professions at the University of Arkansas found that field trips to cultural institutions have significant benefits for students beyond educational aspects.
“We found that students who attended a school tour at Crystal Bridges demonstrated stronger critical thinking skills, displayed higher levels of tolerance, had more historical empathy and developed a taste for being a cultural consumer in the future,” said Jay Greene, one of the researchers. “We also found that these benefits were much larger, in general, for students from rural areas or high-poverty schools, as well as minority students.”
The researchers announced the results of a study analyzing the impact of school field trips to Crystal Bridges Museum of American Art on students in grades K-12. Greene, professor of education reform; Brian Kisida, senior research associate; and Dan Bowen, doctoral student in education policy, surveyed nearly 11,000 students and 500 teachers at more than 120 schools.
“This research is the first large-scale, randomized, controlled trial measuring what students learn from school tours of an art museum,” Kisida said during the announcement Monday morning at Crystal Bridges.
The journal Education Next, a publication of Harvard University, Stanford University and the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, published an article Sept. 16 with the findings. The study is part of a larger research initiative that Greene and Kisida are pursuing to shed light on the effects of arts and culture in education. The research offers implications for everyone from parents to policymakers.
A $10 million gift to the museum from the Willard and Pat Walker Charitable Foundation of Springdale provided funds for school groups to visit the museum, including transportation, substitute teachers, lunch and educational materials.
Each school visit includes a one-hour guided tour of the museum’s permanent collection, a discussion and activity session around a theme and lunch at the museum’s restaurant. Teachers are able to choose from several themed tours, each designed to connect with Common Core standards at a variety of grade levels in art, history, social studies, language arts and sciences.
“Since Crystal Bridges is in an area where an art museum had not previously existed, and because the field trip is free to schools, we had high demand for the tours and decided to select participants via a random lottery,” said Anne Kraybill, Crystal Bridges’ school programs manager. “In initial meetings with the University of Arkansas, it became clear that this lottery system would provide the right conditions for conducting research.”
Crystal Bridges received 525 applications from school groups representing 38,347 K-12 students during the first two semesters of the school tour program. Greene, Kisida and Bowen matched pairs among the applicants based on similarity in grade level and other demographic factors. Within each pair, the researchers randomly assigned which applicant would be in the “treatment group” – the group that would receive a tour that semester – and which would be in the “control group,” whose tour would be deferred to a later time.
The researchers administered surveys to all of the students several weeks after the students in the treatment group visited the museum. The surveys included multiple items that assessed knowledge about art, as well as measures of tolerance, historical empathy, critical thinking and sustained interest in visiting art museums and other cultural institutions.
“Our research suggests that students actually retain a great deal of factual information from their tours, as students who received a tour of Crystal Bridges were able to recall details about the paintings they had seen at very high rates,” Greene said.
For example, 88 percent of the students who saw the Eastman Johnson painting, At the Camp – Spinning Yarns and Whittling, knew when surveyed weeks later that the painting depicts abolitionists making maple syrup to undermine the sugar industry, which relied upon slave labor. Among students who saw Thomas Hart Benton’s Ploughing It Under, 79 percent could recall that it is a depiction of a farmer destroying his crops as part of a Depression-era price support program.
The researchers assessed students’ critical thinking skills by showing all third- through 12th-graders a painting they had not previously seen and asking them to write short essays in response to two questions: “What do you think is going on in this painting?” and “What do you see that makes you think that?”
Overall, the researchers found that students assigned by lottery to a tour of the museum improved their critical thinking skills relative to the control group. For rural students (who live in towns with fewer than 10,000 people), students from high-poverty schools (those with more than 50 percent receiving free or reduced-price lunches) and minority students, the effect was two to three times larger.
“Culturally enriching field trips are in decline in public education, and museums across the country report a steep drop in school tours,” Greene said. “This research shows that the trips have significant benefits and particularly for disadvantaged students. These results should be an important consideration in the assessment and distribution of resources.”
UPDATE: The UA finally got around to answering today our question last Thursday morning about the cost of this “research.” It was put at $109,714 by a professor who refused to answer Thursday and was unavailable for questions Friday. Most of the cost is in the salaries of employees who did the work.