Think Progress does some valuable reporting on one of Tom Cotton’s worst debate blunders last night. He still has no plan for covering the 210,000 Arkansans who now have private option health insurance. But, unbelievably, he says the old high-risk insurance pools were good enough for people with pre-existing illnesses. Obamacare requires coverage for all now.

Mark Pryor, cancer survivor, knows the reality of sick people with nothing more than high-risk insurance pools to fall back on — high prices for poor coverage if coverage is available at all.


Many of the high risk pools Cotton praised were known for their sky-high costs, exclusion of many applicants, and strict limits on what care is covered. In Arkansas, out of pocket costs for patients in such pools could be as high as $20,000 and those with pre-existing conditions had an average 6 month waiting period for care.

Americans who could not afford or qualify for the program and lacked an offer of employer-based coverage, were forced to turn to the individual health care market, where they were routinely denied coverage. Common disqualifications included diabetes, hepatitis C, multiple sclerosis, schizophrenia, quadriplegia, Parkinson’s disease and AIDS/HIV or even relatively mild health issues like acne.

As Pryor noted in the debate, before the Affordable Care Act went into effect, “people in Arkansas with pre-existing conditions were routinely denied access to coverage. They were one medical emergency away from bankruptcy. The insurance companies had all the power. I think that it would be a mistake to go back to those days.” He then accused Cotton of having “no answer” for what would happen to such people were the nation to “start
over” on health care reform—as Cotton has repeatedly advocated.

Think Progress also corrected Cotton on his misleading remarks on Walmart’s end of insurance for part-time employees.


“Those people at Walmart or other companies do not want an option. They want their health insurance,” he said. “They are feeling the pain and stress of losing their insurance and trying to find a better option when they have an exact plan that suited their needs.”

But whether the Walmart plan ever suited the needs of its workers is up for debate. Most plans available to part-time workers at the company were prohibitively expensive and came with high deductibles that would make it difficult to pay for a major illness or surgery. And according to a study by consulting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers earlier this year, the workers will likely be able to find more comprehensive and cheaper plans on the private exchange market. The low wages Walmart pays would almost certainly qualify them for a federal subsidy or Medicaid coverage.

No wonder Republicans want to focus on Mark Pryor’s stumble in saying — as presidential nominee Mitt Romney once did — that some people consider middle income as high as $200,000. Who really is looking out for the middle class. Not Tom Cotton, with his vow to throw 210,000 working people and families off insurance.